Note: This blog expands on my interview on BBC World Service Newsday programme on 19th January.

Squirrels don’t have GPS and mobile technology.  They’ve got to remember where they hid all their nuts. Fortunately for them, and lots of other creatures that depend on their partial amnesia, they are sub-optimal in the nut recollection front. Imagine if they had a NUTS APP! Not a nut would go unchewed.

You’d see them stumbling across the forest floor, mobile device in hand, connecting to a series of satellites far above them in space, triangulating the exact position of each nut stash.  Optimized nut foraging, and all for £20 a year!  The NUTS APP would transform their little lives. Yet…

…there would be no more oak trees, since all the baby oaks (acorns) would have been eaten.  This means that eventually, there would be no more acorns, and…no more squirrels. Yet for the current generation of squirrels, this would not be a present risk, and so the NUTS APP might seem the only way to go. After all, when a bad winter came you could share your stash of nuts with those “developing” squirrels that didn’t have the APP, at a small cost. What would be wrong with that? And then you could teach them to use the NUTS APP, for a small licence fee.

But squirrels don’t do this, and foxes don’t eat all the rabbits either.  DNA is not perfectly repaired, allowing cancers to develop but also allowing mutations to build at an appropriate rate.  Nature is not optimal at any one level of organization, but rather is suboptimal at each level, for the greater good. 

This is because nature can only be understood using system theory, not reductionism. It isn’t made out of little boxes and it can’t be built from genes or memes.  It is an emergent property. And so we should expect sub-optimality at every level.  I have written about this in depth in my recent book, Escape from Bubbleworld: Seven Curves to Save the Earth, available on Amazon.

Yet we have moved far from this approach, especially in the West.  Western Consumerism has spread, becoming the global aspiration.  Why is this? There are two reasons.  Firstly the underlying philosophy that underpins all of the Western World’s social and economic principles, known as Enlightenment thinking, and secondly, the desire to make this philosophy the new world order, delivered globally through Development, and, in its most recent apparition, dressed up in pretty green ribbons, Sustainable Development.  This is the subject of my most recent book, Sustainable Economics: Context, Challenges and Opportunities. Let’s look at these two points briefly.

1. The underlying philosophy of the Western World.

The Enlightenment was, ironically, probably the darkest moment in recent human history, and indeed, natural history too. Just like the NUTS APP, it seemed like the greatest thing, but while ridding us of Church and State control was a good thing, ridding us of the bonds that tied us to nature was to spell our doom.  Nature holds no limits to the human race, cried Condorcet, the French philosopher.  Gone would be the tyranny of nature – the threats of famine, flood and disease.  The old horses of the apocalypse would be laid to rest, as humans, and humans alone would solve their own problems through technology and reason.  Optimization had begun, where we would all be supplied with NUTS APPS and harvest the bountiful supply of resources of the natural world.  This was the optimization of the human condition, where nature, as source and sink, would be made to bow before us. Its enslavement echoed the slavery of our fellow humans. Western Consumerism was unleased, supported by a philosophy that would become so deeply ingrained that we would come to view it as our natural state.

2. The problem with Development

As if this wasn’t bad enough, we then set about enforcing this philosophy on the rest of the world.  This really accelerated after World War II, where a new order was imagined, with global organizations such as the UN, IMF and World Bank delivering Enlightenment social and economic practice across the globe.  Development was the term that was used, converting the “developing” world into the “developed world”. Everyone would be given a free NUTS APP, and we could all aspire to a Western philosophy of reductionist, optimized and humanist thinking.

Yet as the last oaks fall, and the final stash of nuts has been located on the APP, we may finally realize that optimizing for the human condition was folly, that we live within an emergent system, not a reductionist Legoland, and that squirrel amnesia, not the NUTS APP, would have been the best way forward.

 


Comments

02/06/2016 10:18am

I just loved your concept of nut's app comparing with the squirrels. The way both are interlinked with the lifestyle and embracing the new life style just like the squirrel, it's a good comparison.

Reply
03/01/2017 11:55pm

Beard Czar you what is going to show up if you go for the cheaper hair straighteners. good judgment says that if you could get your hair directly with the inexpensive Beard Czar hair straightener then why spends greater that offers the same result.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/beard-czar/

Reply
03/19/2016 9:38am

Sustainable Energy is one which is able to meet the growing demand of today’s people without compromising the demand of the people that would require it in future. All renewable energy sources like solar, wind, geothermal, hydropower, wave and tidal power are forms of sustainable energy. These energy sources have been here since centuries and are here to stay till life is available on earth. Renewable energy sources have low environmental impact, widely available and are naturally replenished.Read more at Gaslicht.com

Reply
03/02/2017 9:47pm

Apex Vitality Booty Pop to ask for a professional help after they have this kind of circumstance.girls may not recognize it for now that they'll come a time that their Apex Vitality Booty Pop $exual urges may also come to a decrease or worse come to an end.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/apex-vitality-booty-pop/

Reply
03/23/2016 10:01am

This is really very informative blog. I love such kind of informative sites.

Reply
03/03/2017 9:43pm

Priamax Male Enhancement such merchandise promote hair increase while implemented to regions which are balding and wishes to be used continually Priamax Male Enhancement until the desired growth of hair is met.there is an ongoing debate as to whether or now not taking.

http://guidemesupplements.com/priamax-male-enhancement/

Reply
04/05/2016 9:02am

I never thought this kind of idea before. Thanks you've made it.

Reply
04/27/2016 3:41pm

It's my fortune I found this article today. I really need this info for my assignment. Thank you.

Reply
03/06/2017 2:24am

Max Grow Xtreme pheromones collectively pressure melancholy tension and positive health troubles are a number of the foremost reasons of erectile disorder or Max Grow Xtreme male impotence nowadays it additionally called the incapacity to achieve.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/max-grow-xtreme/

Reply
03/06/2017 9:44pm

Beard Czar however in case your hair is pretty an awful lot workable and also you need a hair straightener only for the unique activities which could call for its utilization Beard Czar then you definitely might need to get the sort that works for that as properly.

http://guidemesupplements.com/beard-czar/

Reply
03/07/2017 10:06pm

Priamax Male Enhancement muscles is a result of calculated restraint. aggressive dangers will only set you lower back from the dreams you have designed.Priamax Male Enhancement the sports supplements which are most beneficial in building frame muscle groups .

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/priamax-male-enhancement/

Reply
03/08/2017 10:19pm

Testo Ultra it less difficult for someone to shed pounds. as soon as the favored weight is taken off there s a higher chance of it staying off. human beings who take progressive Testo Ultra regularly can enjoy an improvement in hormone stability.

http://boostupmuscles.com/testo-ultra/

Reply
03/09/2017 10:06pm

Better Beard Club select shampoo and conditioner that appropriate in your hair.laser hair removal is one which you can take severely in case you need to remove that Better Beard Club hair growing for your butt on your legs or in your again.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/better-beard-club/

Reply
03/10/2017 9:39pm

Better Beard Club look higher with a moisturizing shampoo as well. coarse curly and dry hair do not typically need to be washed each day and can appearance exceptional Better Beard Club with just one wash a week the use of a moisturizing shampoo.

http://guidemesupplements.com/better-beard-club/

Reply
03/14/2017 12:45am

Pure Nitro Max burning energy at an greatest charge you need to hold your metabolism at premiere levels. you may accomplish this by way of eating small meals at Pure Nitro Max ordinary duration each three to 4 hours. in this manner you maintain encourage.

http://guidemesupplements.com/pure-nitro-max/

Reply
03/14/2017 10:45pm

Nitrobuild Plus regardless of what sort of building muscle mass ordinary you choose to use for your own private goals there are some keys to success which apply.Nitrobuild Plus constructing muscle groups is not easy and there is no miracle drug in an effort to make it clean.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/nitrobuild-plus/

Reply
03/15/2017 10:47pm

Vigor Excel your doctor has stated so. preserve a healthier and be a brand new you with lyriana.fortunately for a few girls they were endowed with exceptional plump breasts. Vigor Excel whilst some girls who discover themselves inadequate on.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/vigor-excel/

Reply
03/16/2017 10:33pm

Nuvella Serum pores and skin care due to the fact we often suppose that the skin is so thick that not anything we placed on it is going to be virtually absorbed into our machine. Nuvella Serum in truth that is incredibly genuine one of the essential features of the skin.

http://boostupmuscles.com/nuvella-serum-canada/

Reply
03/17/2017 10:39pm

Testo Edge Ex you and leaves you equipped to work out once more that day.muscle relaxants are drugs help alleviate pain which are introduced with the aid of traces sprains Testo Edge Ex muscle spasms and other muscle injuries.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/testo-edge-ex/

Reply
03/19/2017 10:51pm

Alpha Monster Advanced experts suggest supplementing your weight loss plan with protein powders sports bars or meal substitute liquids.Alpha Monster Advanced these dietary supplements are very handy and make it smooth to determine.

http://www.musclesciencefacts.com/alpha-monster-advanced/

Reply
03/21/2017 2:56am

Endovex Male Enhancement a partner for a social occasion.male escorts normally paintings via an escort corporation and the company will be accountable to set Endovex Male Enhancement up the dates for a small rate. male escorts may be booked for a day some hours.

http://www.musclesciencefacts.com/endovex-male-enhancement/

Reply
03/21/2017 11:16pm

Focus Max which you have in no way heard of and also steer clear of discount fitness plans which are not actual coverage and are highly unstable leaving you unprotected Focus Max for most of the price of a big medical bill.

http://www.guia-mesuplemento.br.com/focus-max/

Reply
03/23/2017 10:38pm

Endovex Male Enhancement considering no chemical is carried out in those pills they don't have any possible aspect results as in case of the first circle of relatives of weight reduction drugs. Endovex Male Enhancement irrespective of which route.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/endovex-male-enhancement/

Reply

Endovex Male Enhancement color tints are the fave lens of individuals who need to make a totally dramatic exchange of their eye coloration one so that it will right away Endovex Male Enhancement draw close the eye of each person in the room.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/endovex-male-enhancement/

Reply
03/26/2017 10:44pm

Andro Beast to retaining wholesome organs. creative and protein provides vitamins to the numerous aspects of power training and packs it multi function superb supplement. Andro Beast glycogen will become an essential player.

http://www.musclesciencefacts.com/andro-beast/

Reply
03/27/2017 10:34pm

Andro Enhance you want to be the use of creative and a few type of whey-isolate protein powder. you pretty a whole lot can't pass wrong with those. i will say although Andro Enhance if you have liver or kidney problems speak along with your medical doctor before taking creative.

http://www.musclesciencefacts.com/andro-enhance/

Reply
03/28/2017 11:05pm

ACTUS capable of come across any type of studying or brain deficiencies that exist inside the thoughts of the child and that is what you actually need on the way ACTUS to cognizance on. that is why maximum baby psychologists accessible.

http://cuidados-saude.br.com/actus/

Reply
03/29/2017 10:57pm

Enhance Mind IQ mustang overall performance chips and tuners will enhance upon the inventory tune and supply a more competitive and extra green tune to the auto. Enhance Mind IQ there are a few which have a using coach to assist the ones people in our using.

http://www.musclesciencefacts.com/enhance-mind-iq/

Reply
03/30/2017 10:44pm

Endovex is that the quantity of outbreaks diminishes over the years.in the interim there are not any to be had therapies for genital herpes infections. Endovex anti-viral medicinal drugs like familiar acyclovir and other comparable pills.

http://guidemesupplements.com/endovex/

Reply
03/31/2017 10:17pm

Force Factor VolcaNO so in case your severe approximately experiencing most muscle boom you want to understand your frame kind use an effective Force Factor VolcaNO workout plan designed in your frame type and desires and feed your frame with the right meals in the best amounts.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/force-factor-volcano/

Reply
04/02/2017 11:06pm

Ultimate Alpha Extreme then he just is going off sulking inside the corner somewhere.an alpha male will take rejection from a female at the chin and just laugh it off and flow on. Ultimate Alpha Extreme to have true confidence manner you can take delivery of rejection.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/ultimate-alpha-extreme/

Reply
04/03/2017 11:05pm

Ultimate Alpha Extreme as a end result this newsletter will undergo a step-with the aid of-step breast enhancement evaluate highlighting what is typically to be expected Ultimate Alpha Extreme with the aid of someone undergoing this surgical operation.

http://guidemesupplements.com/ultimate-alpha-extreme-users/

Reply
04/04/2017 10:39pm

Andronite Enhanced health experts recommendation to eat the weight loss program drugs and weight reduction dietary supplements together with Andronite Enhanced a balanced weight-reduction plan each time. and the coolest quality weight-reduction plan tablets and weight loss.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/andronite-enhanced/

Reply
04/05/2017 10:41pm

Endovex Viagra to deal with erectile dysfunction and accelerate the sexual power of fellows who feel not able to reaching an erection once they want. Endovex it's far a fda accredited medicinal drug to deal with male impotence.

http://musclegainfast.com/endovex/

Reply
04/06/2017 10:16pm

Ripped Max Muscle years of wasted time specifically in case you are one of those guys or gals that have to work their butt off just to feature a molecule of muscle to their body. Ripped Max Muscle in case you really need to construct muscle and rework.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/ripped-max-muscle/

Reply
04/09/2017 10:57pm

Xtreme Exo-Test this reasons a brief swelling. it s only a reflection of how lengthy your muscle tissues had been under the tension at the same time as running out. Xtreme Exo-Test now not how a whole lot muscle you are constructing.

http://guidemesupplements.com/xtreme-exo-test/

Reply
04/10/2017 10:26pm

Skin Novela a few easy suggestions and strategies only for sensitive pores and skin care you could discover that your skin responds very well and may absolutely be healthy and radiant. Skin Novela what are a few things you need to keep in mind for touchy.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/skin-novela/

Reply
04/12/2017 2:47am

Chantel St Claire paying special near interest to the facial pores and skin. a spf of 30 or better is a superb concept. the fine anti-getting old treatment for your pores and skin is a good sunscreen. Chantel St Claire the usage of it within.

http://boostupmuscles.com/chantel-st-claire/

Reply
04/12/2017 11:07pm

Ultra Boost Force milk plays an antioxidant role while improving hormonal and mobile responses. the aspect effects of muscle milk are minimal as long as the right Ultra Boost Force dosage commands of muscle milk protein consumption are observed.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/ultra-boost-force/

Reply
04/13/2017 11:04pm

Dermabellix software of herbal merchandise no longer simplest avoids the prevalence of numerous aspect outcomes but also affords a herbal glow to the skin which Dermabellix lasts plenty longer.from time to time after the mosquito bites.

http://guidemesupplements.com/dermabellix/

Reply
04/14/2017 11:43pm

Vlamorous per-mature wrinkles can also be avoided through eating a nicely-balanced food regimen ingesting numerous water and warding off materials which can be harmful Vlamorous for pores and skin fitness.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/vlamorous/

Reply
04/16/2017 10:41pm

Endovex the query approximately whether or not the evaluations are fabricated or genuine is beside the point. whether or not the tablet reasons natural penis Endovex expansion or not is responded in that declaration too.

http://www.strongtesterone.com/endovex/

Reply
04/18/2017 10:17pm

Avalure by following a skin care software you can shield your pores and skin from the harmful rays of the sun and the harmful environmental elements. Avalure the protection will help your skin be healthier and likely avoid severe problems like skin most cancers.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/avalure-anti-aging-face-cream/

Reply
04/19/2017 10:06pm

Garcinia Shaping Pro the weight reduction magazine may be a superb device within the war to lose kilos. you can report the steps you need to take to lose weight Garcinia Shaping Pro and the development you've got made. a journal can provide a manner.

http://guidemesupplements.com/garcinia-shaping-pro/

Reply



Leave a Reply